Sekinin barai: Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
mNo edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Sekinin barai''' {{kana|責任払い}}, or the rule of '''pao''' {{kana|パオ}}, is a liability payment imposed when a player confirms another player's [[yaku]] / [[yakuman]]. It is almost exclusively used for yakuman, but some rulesets invoke this rule for [[rinshan]]. Not all rulesets use sekinin barai in the first place.
'''Sekinin barai''' {{kana|責任払い}}, or the rule of '''pao''' {{kana|パオ}}, is a liability payment imposed when a player confirms another player's [[yaku]] / [[yakuman]]. It is almost exclusively used for yakuman, but some rulesets invoke this rule for [[rinshan]]. Not all rulesets use sekinin barai.


== Rule overview ==
== Rule overview ==
Line 102: Line 102:
However, when the last group of a yakuman is called for an open [[kan]], the discarder is still liable for pao. Even though the yakuman already existed without needing the kan, pao is still applied.
However, when the last group of a yakuman is called for an open [[kan]], the discarder is still liable for pao. Even though the yakuman already existed without needing the kan, pao is still applied.


To explain how liability works in terms of "the player is responsible for ensuring a yakuman", it is better to switch to the opponent's point of view. When a yakuman-holder has called for two groups of dragons, daisangen is not guaranteed ''in the opponent's eyes''. Once an opponent discards the third dragon, and it is called for a kan, daisangen becomes guaranteed ''in the opponent's eyes''. So, when discarding a tile used for a kan, pao is still invoked: from the opponent's point of view, daisangen goes from not guaranteed -> guaranteed.
To explain how liability works in terms of "the player is responsible for ensuring a yakuman", it is better to switch to the opponent's point of view. When a yakuman-holder has called for two groups of dragons, daisangen is not guaranteed ''in the opponent's view''. Once an opponent discards the third dragon, and it is called for a kan, daisangen becomes guaranteed ''in the opponent's view''. So, when discarding a tile used for a kan, pao is still invoked: from the opponent's point of view, daisangen goes from not guaranteed -> guaranteed.


'''Example''':
'''Example''':


Suppose a player completed a daisangen, and the hand looks like the following one in his view:
Suppose a player completed a daisangen, and the hand looks like the following one in his view:
: {{#mjt:1234m}}, last: {{#mjt:666'6z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Main perspective)
: {{#mjt:1234m}}, last: {{#mjt:666'6z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Winner's perspective)
Toimen becomes the liable player since they allowed the call from the last dragon group. From the winner's perspective, the yakuman was already completed (see below).
Toimen becomes the liable player since they allowed the call from the last dragon group. From the winner's perspective, the yakuman was already completed (see below).
: {{#mjt:1234m666z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Main perspective)
: {{#mjt:1234m666z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Winner's perspective)
However, from the opponent's point of view, the daisangen is not guaranteed.
However, from the opponent's point of view, the daisangen is not guaranteed.
: {{#mjt:0000000z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Opponent's view)
: {{#mjt:0000000z}}, second: {{#mjt:5'55z}}, first: {{#mjt:77'7z}} (Opponent's view)
Line 121: Line 121:
The relationship of liability is established for toimen, for becoming the feeder of last required set.
The relationship of liability is established for toimen, for becoming the feeder of last required set.


This rule also implies a useful strategy of gameplay:
This means:
* If a call confirms an ensured yakuman, the opponents should have avoided discarding such tile to get rid of the liability.
* If a call confirms an ensured yakuman, the opponents should have avoided discarding such tile to avoid the liability.
* If a call doesn't guarantee a yakuman, the opponents can discard it safely without liability.
* If a call doesn't guarantee a yakuman, the opponents can discard it without liability (but with some risk of dealing in normally).


== Yakuman without sekinin barai ==
== Yakuman without sekinin barai ==
In general, sekinin barai does not apply to other yakuman, since other types of yakuman cannot be ensured even with all required sets are melded. A common point for these yakuman hands is that they both have some limitation of toitsu (the head pair).
In general, sekinin barai does not apply to other yakuman, since other types of yakuman cannot be ensured even with all required sets are melded. A common point for these yakuman hands is that they all have some requirement for the hand's pair.


==== Shousuushi ====
'''Shousuushi'''
: {{#mjt:0000z}} {{#mjt:4'44z}} {{#mjt:33'3z}} {{#mjt:2'22z}}
: {{#mjt:4456s}} {{#mjt:4'44z}} {{#mjt:33'3z}} {{#mjt:2'22z}}
: {{#mjt:4456s}} {{#mjt:4'44z}} {{#mjt:33'3z}} {{#mjt:2'22z}}
: Honitsu + possible yakuhai hand. Shousuushi is not ensured.
: Honitsu + possible yakuhai hand. Shousuushi is not ensured.
==== Tsuuiisou ====
'''Tsuuiisou'''
: {{#mjt:0z}} {{#mjt:6'66z}} {{#mjt:3'33z}} {{#mjt:77"7z}} {{#mjt:4'44z}}
: {{#mjt:2s}} {{#mjt:6'66z}} {{#mjt:3'33z}} {{#mjt:77"7z}} {{#mjt:4'44z}}
: {{#mjt:2s}} {{#mjt:6'66z}} {{#mjt:3'33z}} {{#mjt:77"7z}} {{#mjt:4'44z}}
: Toitoi + yakuhai + honitsu hand. Tsuuiisou is not ensured.
: Toitoi + yakuhai + honitsu hand. Tsuuiisou is not ensured.
==== Chinroutou ====
'''Chinroutou'''
: {{#mjt:0z}} {{#mjt:111"p}} {{#mjt:1'11s}} {{#mjt:999'9m}} {{#mjt:999'p}}
: {{#mjt:8m}} {{#mjt:111"p}} {{#mjt:1'11s}} {{#mjt:999'9m}} {{#mjt:999'p}}
: {{#mjt:8m}} {{#mjt:111"p}} {{#mjt:1'11s}} {{#mjt:999'9m}} {{#mjt:999'p}}
: Toitoi-nomi hand. Chinroutou is not ensured.
: Toitoi-nomi hand. Chinroutou is not ensured.
==== Ryuuiisou ====
'''Ryuuiisou'''
: {{#mjt:0z}} {{#mjt:22'2s}} {{#mjt:4'23s}} {{#mjt:0z88s0z}} {{#mjt:66'6z}}
: {{#mjt:1s}} {{#mjt:22'2s}} {{#mjt:4'23s}} {{#mjt:0z88s0z}} {{#mjt:66'6z}}
: {{#mjt:1s}} {{#mjt:22'2s}} {{#mjt:4'23s}} {{#mjt:0z88s0z}} {{#mjt:66'6z}}
: Honitsu + yakuhai hatsu hand. Ryuuiisou is not ensured.
: Honitsu + yakuhai hatsu hand. Ryuuiisou is not ensured.
1,741

edits