Bureaucrats, checkuser, Administrators
10,054
edits
Talk:Local yaku: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
→Reviews
Tempara-chan (talk | contribs) |
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit |
||
| Line 120: | Line 120: | ||
A temporary page [[Local_yaku/extensions]] was created for holding more local yaku, considering there're potentially more terms to fit in the future, for the people to quickly check the definitions while focusing less about the origins. Terms can first be complement and improved, until it becomes more reliable to fill in the main page. --[[User:Kator278|Kator278]] ([[User talk:Kator278|talk]]) 18:38, 14 February 2025 (UTC) | A temporary page [[Local_yaku/extensions]] was created for holding more local yaku, considering there're potentially more terms to fit in the future, for the people to quickly check the definitions while focusing less about the origins. Terms can first be complement and improved, until it becomes more reliable to fill in the main page. --[[User:Kator278|Kator278]] ([[User talk:Kator278|talk]]) 18:38, 14 February 2025 (UTC) | ||
=== About local yaku === | |||
The real question: '''What is our goal with listing local yaku?''' In general, mahjong enables anyone to come up with all sorts of patterns. If I really want to, I can make some up right now. Imagine specific yaku to be added just for chiitoitsu, for example. We know these patterns exist, and some are used in riichi mahjong apps. The main contention is what to include vs what not to include. For this Wiki, we're primarily interested in the ones used or at the very least usable in riichi to play around with. Otherwise, patterns become trivial and/or better left off in the other variants. For the scope of this Wiki, we rely at the very least [https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/メインページ Japanese Wikipedia] along with other sources and writings. With regards to local yaku, I haven't examined their listing. For additional opinions, I linked this discussion in [https://discord.gg/6emgTqTwPm Mahjong Discord]. [[User:KyuuAA|KyuuAA]] ([[User_talk:KyuuAA|Talk:キュウ]]) 02:13, 16 February 2025 (UTC) | |||
== Sanma? == | == Sanma? == | ||
This wiki's handling of alternate [[Sanma|sanma]] rulesets is generally quite limited, which extends to this page aswell. The problem is, while alot of rule variations apply to both yonma and sanma, there are alot of rules and yaku that are generally only used in 3-player rulesets. Additionally, some yaku like daisharin and shousharin exist in yonma, but are almost always defined differently when used in sanma. Should these be included in this page, included under their own heading or have their own page entirely? I'd be in favor of the second option. [[User:Tempara-chan|Tempara-chan]] ([[User talk:Tempara-chan|talk]]) 14:22, 10 February 2025 (UTC) | This wiki's handling of alternate [[Sanma|sanma]] rulesets is generally quite limited, which extends to this page aswell. The problem is, while alot of rule variations apply to both yonma and sanma, there are alot of rules and yaku that are generally only used in 3-player rulesets. Additionally, some yaku like daisharin and shousharin exist in yonma, but are almost always defined differently when used in sanma. Should these be included in this page, included under their own heading or have their own page entirely? I'd be in favor of the second option. [[User:Tempara-chan|Tempara-chan]] ([[User talk:Tempara-chan|talk]]) 14:22, 10 February 2025 (UTC) | ||