Yaku compatibility: Difference between revisions

improve the intro. put the two separate interpretations into bullet points. junchan is the one that is only terminals, it doesn't allow onors
mNo edit summary
(improve the intro. put the two separate interpretations into bullet points. junchan is the one that is only terminals, it doesn't allow onors)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Image:Junchan sanshoku baiman.jpg|thumb|right|250px|A single hand composed of six yaku to produce a baiman hand.]]
[[Image:Junchan sanshoku baiman.jpg|thumb|right|250px|A single hand composed of six yaku to produce a baiman hand.]]


This is a table showing the compatibilities of the different [[yaku]] with each other. While yaku may be combined in one hand, some yaku simply cannot combine with each other due to tile counts and patterns. In other cases, one yaku would always imply another. For instance, a [[junchan]] hand has a terminal or honor in every group. So it would qualify for [[chanta]] for having a terminal in every group. By rule, two yaku cannot be combined if one always implies the other. There is a partial exception to this as [[shousangen]] always implies at least two [[yakuhai]] for sets of dragons, but they are not necessarily the same two yakuhai so they are counted in addition.
This is a table showing the compatibilities of the different [[yaku]] with each other. While yaku may be combined in one hand, it is simply impossible to combine certain yaku with each other.
 
Alternatively, some yaku would always imply another. For instance, a [[junchan]] hand has a terminal in every group. This also fits the definition of [[chanta]], which mandates that the hand has a terminal or honor in each group. Every junchan hand is a chanta hand, so chanta is not scored. By rule, two yaku cannot be combined if one always implies the other. (A partial exception is with [[shousangen]]. Shousangen always implies two dragon yakuhai, but does not always imply you have any one of "haku", "hatsu", or "chun".)


== Yaku ==
== Yaku ==
Line 62: Line 64:
|}
|}


Yaku strategy involves viability to form yaku and maximizing hand value, if possible. This maximization often involves the recognition of the different yaku forming in one hand.  Often, this affects the decision which tiles to keep and which to discard.
Yaku strategy involves viability to form yaku and maximizing hand value, if possible. This maximization often involves the recognition of the different yaku forming in one hand.  Often, this affects the decision which tiles to keep and which to discard.


Three combinations actually form yakuman:
Three combinations actually form yakuman:
Line 69: Line 71:
* Toitoi + Mentsumo = Suuankou
* Toitoi + Mentsumo = Suuankou
* Honroutou + Junchan = Chinroutou
* Honroutou + Junchan = Chinroutou
* Daburu riichi + Chankan is only possible with a Kokushi musou hand


Some combinations form a different yaku which implies one component of the combination, and as a result can never be counted:
Some combinations form a different yaku which implies one component of the combination, and as a result can never be counted:
Line 80: Line 83:
These combinations are marked with {{or}} in the table below.
These combinations are marked with {{or}} in the table below.


Whether or not these combinations are actually combinations depends on the technical definition of the yaku. Some yaku are restricted versions of other yaku, such as junchan and chanta. There are two alternative ways to define this in the rules: either chanta can require that the hand contain at least one honour tile, or it can allow no honour terminals, but with a separate rule saying that chanta and junchan cannot both be counted. In this case, since junchan is higher-scoring, any chanta hand without honours, while qualifying for chanta, would never score it. Most of these combinations, with the exception of toitoi + mentsumo, are based on the assumption that the yaku are defined using the second method.
Whether or not these combinations are actually combinations depends on the technical definition of the yaku. Some yaku are restricted versions of other yaku, such as junchan and chanta. There are two alternative ways to define this in the rules:  
*Chanta is scored when there are honors/terminals in each group, and ''requires'' that the hand contains at least one honor tile.
*Chanta is scored when there are honors/terminals in each group (not requiring an honor tile). However, if a hand is eligible for both chanta and junchan, only one can be scored. Since junchan is the more valuable yaku, it is always the one scored.
 
Most of these combinations, with the exception of toitoi + mentsumo, are based on the assumption that the yaku are defined using the second method.


[[Nagashi mangan]] is excluded, because it is incompatible with anything, even riichi.
[[Nagashi mangan]] is excluded, because it is incompatible with anything, even riichi.
1,758

edits